Underinsurance: The Hidden Risk for Affluent Households
Wealthy households are more likely to be underinsured than they think. Here's how it happens and what it costs.
It seems counterintuitive, but affluent households are often more underinsured than average ones. Wealth tends to grow quietly: a renovation here, an art purchase there, a watch received as a gift. Meanwhile, the sums insured on the policy stay where they were set years ago. You only find out at claim time.
How underinsurance creeps in
- Renovations and extensions that add significant rebuild value but are never declared
- Building cost inflation: materials and labour rise every year, so last decade's rebuild value no longer stretches as far
- New purchases like furniture, art, electronics and jewellery added to the home without updating the policy
- Rising values of gold, diamonds, collectable watches and art
- Set-and-forget renewals, where a policy rolls over year after year without a review
What the average clause does
Most South African home and contents policies include an average clause. If your sum insured is lower than the true value of what's insured, the insurer treats you as carrying the shortfall yourself, and reduces every claim in the same proportion.
A worked example
Say your home would cost R8,000,000 to rebuild today, but it's insured for R5,000,000, a figure set before your renovation. You're insured for 62.5% of its true value.
A fire damages the kitchen and living areas, and repairs cost R1,600,000. You might expect the insurer to pay the full R1,600,000. With average applied, it pays 62.5%: R1,000,000. The remaining R600,000 is yours to fund.
The same applies to contents. Insure contents worth R3,000,000 for R1,500,000 and a R400,000 burglary claim pays R200,000.
Notice this happens on a partial loss, not only a total one. That's what catches most people out.
How to protect yourself
- Get a professional rebuild valuation for your home, especially if it's architect-designed, older or recently renovated.
- List your contents room by room at what it would cost to replace everything new today.
- Specify high-value items individually, with current valuations.
- Review annually, and update your cover after every major purchase or renovation.
- Ask about cover for inflation, so your sums insured keep pace between reviews.
How Everything.Insure helps
On Everything.Insure you can update your sums insured and add items online at any time, without waiting on a call centre. For higher-value homes, our brokers review your sums insured against current rebuild costs and replacement values, so you're paying for cover that actually pays out in full.
Check your cover: get a quote or request a broker review.
Frequently asked questions
What is underinsurance?
Insuring your home or belongings for less than they would cost to rebuild or replace. It means claims are reduced, even on partial losses.
How does the average clause work?
The insurer pays the same percentage of your claim as the percentage of true value you insured. Insure 62.5% of your home's value, and a claim is paid at 62.5%.
How often should I update my sums insured?
At least once a year, and after any renovation, major purchase or change in the value of your valuables.
Get a Personal.Insure quote in minutes! Compare top insurers like Hollard and Old Mutual Insure and choose the perfect fit.
Get a Quote Now
Mishaya Chettiar
Executive Head and Co-Founder of Everything.Insure